MurderHobo.club

Something clever goes here.

Username88 Incidents

Written by

in

Two different “username88” incidents have led to some reflection on the nature of moderation and online hate.

The first was pretty straightforward, happened a few days ago, someone had accidentally broken a rule on something I was moderating, and after dealing with the first issue, on a whim I decided to warn the person about the 88 at the end of their username. It was most likely their birth year, given the age. So I let them know that the whole 88 thing was a thing we’d seen, and that it could be seen as flagging to the far right, and in a kink community, where there are already various reasons to feel unsafe, it could create some issues for them. They thanked me and changed their username.

The second was a board game board, a conversation, about a board game designer who had done something vile. A user with the unfortunate username to the tune of “mydarkthoughts88”, had posted that he was related to the victims and that yes, the dude was guilty. Of course some folks in the thread pointed out that his username was not helping his credibility, especially with his user history hidden, and this devolved into the usual argument.

One dude had said it was unfair to accuse everyone with 88 in their username of being a Nazi.
I replied with this:

That’s not what happened here. What happened here was that the optics of that user name were pointed out as negative credibility. Because to anyone who knows, they are.

It’s somewhat ridiculous, but that’s just something that being a mod online will put into your head after you deal with it for the tenth or hundredth time.

And you phrase it as, “hey, not sure you are aware of this, but the numbers in your username are something we commonly see Nazis using to flag. It’s dumb, but some people will see the number and distrust you. Especially folks who have a had past harassment.”

You assume the folks are most likely ignorant of it, rather than bad actors, but you don’t want to leave any ground cover.

And they replied, saying that approach was reasonable, while other responses had been less so.
I replied with:

I suspect that might be because unfortunately, over time, being a mod often gives you a flavour of CPTSD, and not everyone has the resources to cope with that.

A big part of it is that when people are anonymous, an unknown number of them are sock puppets. This lets a small group of people create a disproportionate amount of harassment.

I was reflecting on that, and on how I had stepped back from some of my moderating over the years.

A few years back, I left a mod team because, I wasn’t willing to be on a mod team with someone who was demonizing immigrants, and saying that it was different, because he was in Europe, and they were being invaded. To me, that’s all part of the same pie.

I walked away from that project, because it wasn’t worth fighting with a mod team that was mostly apathetic about something like that. For whatever reason, they didn’t see the issue.

I’d said I’d had a reflection, but as I’ve finished typing this up, I’ve lost that thought.

I suppose I can sum this up by saying this: Moderation is hard, mostly because dealing with hateful and fearful people is hard. It’s also important. And there’s a cost to it, not just in the time it takes, but the toll it takes on your patience and tolerance.


I want to be clear, when I say “it’s dumb”, I am referring to the circumstances, I am not criticizing folks who are attempting to keep themselves and others safe, and are making choices on limited information. It’s a hard position to be in, one that many people have the privilege of not being in, often due merely to the circumstance of their birth.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *